An excellent new post on E.L. Wagner's Umbral Musings blog debunks some of the "rules" that are flung around for writers to follow. This is a great selection of such rules, and a fine explanation of how, even though most (though perhaps not all) have some basis in reality, they all need to be taken with a grain (or even a large bag) of salt.
You can read her post here.
Sunday, September 1, 2013
Sunday, August 18, 2013
Review of Join Us In Our Game by Mr Fox
Long ago, after the legendary Ages of Gold and Silver, came the equally legendary Age of Vinyl, wherein music was purveyed by means of twelve-inch black discs that played on both sides. During that lost age, I bought a double album called The Complete Mr Fox, which combined the only two albums released by the titular band. I still have it and play it sometimes, but a few weeks ago I bought Join Us In Our Game, exactly the same content in CD form.
Mr Fox was an English
folk-rock band formed in 1970. The early
70s was a great period for the genre, with classic bands like Fairport
Convention, Steeleye Span and the Albion Band developing their styles, as well
as several lesser-known groups, notably Trees and Mr Fox.
The central members, Bob and
Carole Pegg, were friends of Ashley Hutchings and discussed forming a band with
him after he left Fairport. Their
visions weren't quite the same, though, and while Hutchings formed Steeleye
Span to perform traditional songs and tunes, the Peggs created a band that combined
the feel of the traditional village band — the kind of outfit that switched
seamlessly between the village dance on Saturday night and the chapel on Sunday
morning — with influences from art-rock bands such as the Velvet Underground
and the Third Ear Band.
The line-up on the first
album is Bob on organ, melodeon and whistle; Carole on fiddle; Andrew Massey on
cello; John Myatt on woodwinds; Barry Lyons on bass, and Alun Eden on
drums. The sound is heavily layered, in
contrast to the unified sound of a rock band, creating a dreamlike soundscape
against which Bob and Carole tell their tales.
The songs are mostly (with a
couple of exceptions) rooted in the Yorkshire Dales, the Peggs' adopted home,
but many take the form of macabre fantasy — none more than in the band's title
song. Not to be confused at all with
the children's song of the same name (or the Roald Dahl book, of course) Mr
Fox is a grand guignol tale of a girl's narrow escape from her predatory
(and possibly were-fox) fiancé after she finds out what he does in his mansion
in the forest. Other songs in similar
vein are The Gay Goshawk, about another shapeshifter that leaves the
heroine with a baby with silver eyes; The Hanged Man, about the ghost of
a dead hiker; and Rip Van Winkle, Bob's Yorkshire take about the man who
wakes to find the world he knew long gone.
This sense of loss carries
over into the less fantasy-based songs, such as Salisbury Plain (one of
the few non-Yorkshire songs) and Leaving the Dales, a heartbreaking
lament for a lost way of life — the land of a people who struggled and
failed.
Most of the songs are by Bob
or Carole, but two (Salisbury Plain and Mr Trill's Song, a
delightful tribute to morris dancing) have lyrics by Ashley Hutchings, while Little
Woman, while fitting perfectly into Mr Fox's style, is by Dave Mason of the
progressive-rock band Traffic, who themselves had made the odd foray into folk
rock.
One of the most persistent
problems of Mr Fox's brief existence was lack of funds — they couldn't afford
their own PA, for instance, and were frequently let down by inadequate
equipment provided by the venue — and between the two albums they were forced
to slim down to just the Peggs and the rhythm section. Although this meant losing some of the
layering and texture found on the first album, it gave The Gipsy an
extra rawness and energy.
Mr Fox, 1971: l. to r. Alun Eden, Bob Pegg, Carole Pegg, Barry Lyons
The second album was built
around the 13-minute title track, a strange song that's a combination of
love-story, allegorical journey and tribute to the Dales. It tells of the narrator's love for a gipsy
girl (I'd like to tell you people that I met her at a fair/But I met her in
a pub down by the far side of the square) who won't be tied down. When she goes travelling without saying
goodbye, he follows her through the Dales, meeting local people and commenting
on local traditions, till he catches up, though it's for nothing but a final
farewell in the end. The centrepiece of
the track is an instrumental section featuring Carole's idiosyncratic
fiddle-playing that portrays perfectly the feeling of trudging alone across the
moors.
The remaining songs are more
stylistically varied than on the first album, including a bizarre piece called Aunt
Lucy Broadwood, which Bob has described as the first — and only? —
example of English folk rap. The
title character was an important Edwardian folk-song collector — I recall Bob
saying, when I saw him live around 1980, that he'd always imagined her as
rather a strait-laced woman and wanted to give her one exciting day. Quite a day — she finishes up in Hell.
Another extraordinary track
is Carole's song Mendle, possibly the closest folk-rock has ever got to
pure psychedelia, with a distorted bass playing the lead line in places. The song's about witchcraft, which became a
more prominent element in her post-Mr Fox work — she'd been reading the classic
book on the Pendle witches, Mist Over Pendle, and the otherwise
inexplicable title was allegedly short for Pissed Over Mendle.
Mr Fox never had an easy
ride, partly because the Peggs, especially Bob, had already acquired the
reputation of being prickly, outspoken people who hadn't always endeared
themselves to the folk world. Their
marriage was also in the throes of breakdown, creating enormous tension, and the
band gradually disintegrated after making The Gipsy.
It's probably fair to say
that Mr Fox failed at the time partly due to a lack of resources that created
problems beyond their control, partly because they had the reputation of being
very inconsistent live, but mostly because they simply weren't what the
audiences expected or wanted at the time.
Carole's fiddle-style, for instance, which was based on traditional
English ways of playing, would have sounded scrapy and lacklustre to audiences
used to the Irish-influenced flying-fingers style popular then (and now). In fact, it was perfect for the drone-based, dreamlike music Mr
Fox were playing, and sounds a good deal less strange now.
Both Bob and Carole produced
solo albums during the 70s — for me, the highlight is Bob's stunning 1975
concept album, Ancient Maps, telling of a symbolic fantasy quest — but
none of them are available on CD. Note
to any relevant record companies listening — PUT THIS RIGHT. Since then, they've concentrated more on
folkloric or educational projects, though Bob released a superb CD in the 90s
called The Last Wolf.
Both Mr Fox albums can now
be had, though, for a paltry sum, and I think it's time they enjoyed a
well-deserved revival of interest.
Whether you're interested in folk rock or in macabre fantasy tales — or,
like me, in both — this is an essential CD (or download, if you really must). Perhaps the world is ready for Mr Fox now.
Join Us In Our Game is available on Amazon.co.uk or on Amazon.com
Saturday, August 10, 2013
Stephen Trotter - The First Story I Wrote
Something authors
occasionally do on their blogs is to post the first story they wrote, and I
decided to follow suit.
I remember the
occasion. It was a hot summer's day,
and my grandparents had put a table and chairs out in their garden for the kids
to write or draw on. I had what was
meant to be a drawing-book, but I decided to write a story instead, as well as
illustrating it. I was four years old.
This was the first of
several stories I wrote about a horse called Stephen Trotter (or
stephen-troter, as I originally called him) who for some reason wore a suit and top-hat, before moving on to more ambitious
tales. My brother (three years older)
insisted on "correcting" what I'd written, but I still prefer my
first draft.
I think many of the themes
I've used since — independence and responsibility, aspirations, the abuse of
power — are latent in this story (so latent that they're invisible) but my
narrative technique and characterisation have definitely developed since the
age of four. And my spelling's slightly
better, too.
I've also reproduced one of
my illustrations for the story (Stephen and the man with the teliscop). I think this is an important picture,
showing as it does my wisdom in concentrating on writing rather than art.
once apon a time there
was a Horse called stephen-troter and he pulld a cart and his driver was called
Joe.
one day he was pulling
his cart along when they met a man with a teliscop in his hand. and the man
said stephen coued look throo the teliscop so stephen looked throo it. and he
turned the teliscop upwaeds toords the sky and what does he see he sees a
parashootist coming down and then he said I wish I coued fly in that Aeroplane
said stephen.
Never Mind said Joe phaps
we can hier it.
and then they saw the
parishootists had nealy reeched the ground. stephen shook hands with the
parishootist. and then they hiered aeroplane and had a ride in it.
and then they went Home
and went to sleep.
Friday, August 2, 2013
Sibling Marriage in The Triarchy's Emissary and in History
A high proportion of my
stories are set in one particular world, but my new ebook novelette, TheTriarchy's Emissary, has a very different origin. It came from a shared world project that fell apart before it was
finished, although it left me with a story sufficiently stand-alone to
publish. My task in the world-making,
which suited me down to the ground, was to create the history of the Sheballan
Empire, whose demise provided a background to all the stories.
Several key elements of the
Empire's history play a major part in the story, including the Triarchy of the
title, a triad of priest-kings whose forerunners once ruled a great kingdom,
but who are now essentially a terrorist organisation. And even more prominent is one of the main characters: the dowager
empress Novesh, her own brother's widow.
A crucial aspect of the
empire was that, as the early warrior-emperors (and empresses) gave way to
heirs with no special talent, the attitude grew that the emperors were not only
too sacred to marry anyone but their siblings, they were also too sacred to
sully themselves with the dirty business of ruling the empire. Which meant, of course, that power was
wielded by a variety of ambitious and corrupt ministers and generals.
Royal sibling marriage isn't
unknown in real-world history, most famously in Egypt and the Incan
Empire. Since the latter left no
written records, we know of its customs mainly from the highly biased accounts
of the conquistadors and the somewhat-more-reliable oral traditions passed down
to the descendents of the Incas' subjects.
In the circumstances, we can largely only assume their reasons.
The Egyptians certainly left
written records, but these don't always tell us what we want to know, since
they were often written for the purpose of propaganda, not of history. It can be difficult, for instance, to be
sure just how many Pharaohs actually married their sisters, since the consort
was automatically referred to as his sister, even in cases where Egyptologists
are fairly sure that she was unrelated.
We can be fairly sure that
the main reason (or maybe the excuse) for the practice in both civilisations
was, as in the Sheballan Empire, that the ruler was divine and consequently
could only marry someone equally divine.
Many mythologies portray the gods as marrying incestuously, including
the Greek god Zeus, who married his sister Hera and had a child with another
sister, Demeter.
Was that the only reason,
though? Another plausible motive was to
avoid having annoying in-laws — and, if that sounds like a rather weak joke,
you only have to think how often in history a consort's family has constituted
a major challenge to the royal family.
Two of Henry VIII's wives,
for instance, came from the Howard family, whose head, the Duke of Norfolk, was
one of the most powerful men in the kingdom — and would probably have been even
more powerful if both Howard wives hadn't lost their heads. Jane Seymour gave Henry his heir and
conveniently died of the birth, and her brothers virtually ruled the kingdom
after Henry's death. Today, with a
constitutional monarchy, the Spencers are nothing more than a mild
embarrassment to the Windsors, but five hundred years ago they might have been
raising rebellion to protect the rights of Diana's children.
If we don't know enough
about the Incas' motives and practices, or even the Egyptians', there's rather
more information about the most famous dynasty in western history to practice
sibling marriage: the Ptolemies, who began with Ptolemy Soter, general and
reputed half-brother of Alexander the Great, and finished (barring a six-month
successor) with Cleopatra VII, lover of Caesar, wife of Antony and seductress
of history ever since.
The Ptolemies ruled in Egypt
but, like Alexander, they were Macedonian Greeks. It's been speculated that there may have been some Egyptian or
other African blood in the dynasty by the end — that's not impossible, but
unlikely, and there's certainly no evidence for it. The only non-Macedonian blood known to have flowed in Cleopatra's
veins was actually Persian.
Despite their mythology, the
Greeks — and the Macedonians claimed to be Greek, even if they weren't always
welcome members of the family — had a particular horror of incest. True, their main disgust was aimed at mother-son
relationships, such as Oedipus's, but any hint of incest was distinctly
non-Greek. So what possessed Ptolemy's
family to adopt it so enthusiastically?
Well, for one thing they
were in Egypt. Egyptian culture
fascinated the Greeks, who regarded them as a wise and ancient people, even
while also regarding them as just plain weird.
Although the Macedonian rulers and the Egyptian subjects kept largely
separate, the Ptolemaic king was also crowned Pharaoh, to keep his subjects
happy, and some of the family fell under the spell of Egypt.
The first sibling marriage
in the dynasty was almost certainly a matter of convenience. Ptolemy II was an able ruler, but possibly
not the strongest-willed of men, whereas his big sister Arsinoë knew exactly
what she wanted. Macedonian women could
be formidable, but they didn't have constitutional rights to rule in their own
name — they had to marry a ruler.
Arsinoë had tried this without any great success, and her brother's
first wife (also called Arsinoë — the same names recur a great deal in this
dynasty) had died. Perhaps she knew of
old that she could make her brother do what she wanted. And this was Egypt, so there was a
precedent.
The couple had no children
(Arsinoë was probably past child-bearing age) but she proudly took as her
cult-name Arsinoë Philadelphus: She Who Loves Her Brother. The city of Philadelphia mentioned in the
bible and copied by William Penn and co was named after her. It meant that kind of brotherly love.
Ptolemy III (son of his
father's first marriage) didn't marry his sister, though his wife was a first
cousin, but their son revived the practice.
Ptolemy IV's viciousness was somewhat tempered by his laziness and
obsession with pleasure-seeking, but his favourites made up for the lack,
murdering the entire royal family apart from the King's youngest sister,
another Arsinoë, who was married off to him.
This was certainly to do with having no inconvenient in-laws. Ptolemy's male relatives had had to go
because they might have challenged the favourites, and the King's in-laws could
have had similar power. Poor Arsinoë
had no-one.
In fact, Arsinoë Philopator
seems to have been a remarkable woman.
The great scientist Eratosthenes, who successfully measured the size of
the Earth, had been tutor to the royal children, and he later wrote a memoir
expressing his adoration for her.
Several stories of her life suggest that, like her most famous descendent, she had remarkable charisma.
That didn't help when
Ptolemy died and Arsinoë tried to claim the right to rule as regent for her
infant son. She was assassinated by the
favourites, but the Alexandrian mob rioted at the rumour and lynched them.
Ptolemy V, then, was the son
of siblings, who were the children of first cousins, but there's no sign in him
of any inbreeding problems. That's not
really so surprising. The child of
sibling parents has a slightly higher than normal risk of congenital
abnormalities, but it's still relatively low — it takes two or three
generations of the practice before the threat becomes serious. This pattern may account for the reason why
the various Egyptian dynasties tended to flourish for a few generations and
then decline.
Since he was the only member
left of the royal family, Ptolemy V married a Seleucid princess (Macedonian
rulers of Syria) who brought a new name into the dynasty — Cleopatra. The next few generations, though, were rife
with incestuous marriages; one king married first his sister, who had
previously been married to his elder brother, and then the daughter of his two
siblings.
These Ptolemies and
Cleopatras — vicious and decadent, but showing no sign of debilitating
conditions until perhaps the last generation — fought one another into extinction, leaving only an illegitimate
child to be put on the throne. Ptolemy
XI probably benefited from bringing new blood into the family, though no-one
knows what blood that was. Similarly,
his queen was described as his sister, but this might just have been the old
Egyptian custom, rather than suggesting they were related by blood. Certainly, the most famous of their
children, Cleopatra VII, appeared genuinely interested in Egyptian culture and
frequently dressed up as the goddess Isis.
This has affected the popular image of her appearance, although she was
said to be a redhead under the black wig.
Neither the Incas, the
Egyptian dynasties nor the Ptolemies sustained a run of sibling marriages for
long enough to have the devastating effect on the bloodline that I've portrayed
in The Triarchy's Emissary. The
parallel lack of any political power there meant that having a dribbling idiot
on the throne was no great disadvantage.
Indeed, it could be helpful to those who exercised the true power. Novesh's brother-husband fitted that
description, but Novesh herself — as can happen, even after generations of
inbreeding — somehow escaped the effects.
Like the Ptolemies, her family produced one last magnificent woman at
the very end.
Credits for photos:
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
The Triarchy's Emissary published today
The Triarchy's Emissary
by Nyki Blatchley
Published by Fox & Raven Publishing
Available on Kindle from Amazon.co.uk for £0.77
& from Amazon.com for $1.18
The gods have destroyed the
Empire of Shebal, and the world is in chaos, at the mercy of warlords and
tyrants. Edralit arrives in the city of Faiz with orders that she's to
infiltrate the household of the dowager empress Novesh, who has plans to
restore order—but orders from whom? Is she an assassin sent by the vicious
Triarchy of the Mountains, or does she have another agenda? The young emissary
is captivated by the charismatic empress, but will it stop her fulfilling her
task—whatever that might be?
Buy a copy from Amazon.com or Amazon.co.uk
Monday, July 22, 2013
In Search of the Holy Grail
About fifteen years ago, I started writing a historical fantasy novel set in the 11th century that largely revolved around finding the Holy Grail. It was a good, if flawed, story which I've only recently acknowledged I'm not going to get published, but one of the things I'm now dissatisfied with is my treatment of the Grail.
At
the time, I was aware of three broad models of what the Grail was. There was the idea that it was the cup of
the Last Supper (or, in some alternatives, a cup that had caught the blood from
Christ's wounds on the cross). There
was the idea that it was a thinly disguised version of the Celtic cauldron of
rebirth. My interpretation was
essentially a mash-up of these two, with a bit more emphasis on the second.
The
third model was the one put forward in The Holy Blood and the Holy Grail,
that the Grail legend was a metaphor for the descent of the Frankish
Merovingian Dynasty from Jesus (the vessel containing the blood of
Christ). According to this theory, the
name Sangreal, normally translated as Holy Grail, is actually sang
real - royal blood. I didn't think
much of this theory at the time, and its subsequent notoriety from its use by
Dan Brown hasn't endeared it to me any more.
Brown's
interpretation, in particular, depends on the assumption that this genealogy is
true. This wouldn't matter, of course,
if it were just taken as a good plot for an imaginative novel, but it seems to
have convinced a lot of people.
The
Merovingians were a Germanic dynasty, and it was normal for such dynasties to
claim descent from one or the other of their gods. The current Queen of the United Kingdom, by virtue of being a
scion of the royal house of Wessex, is allegedly a descendent of the god Woden. This kind of creative genealogy is common —
by a similar method, I can possibly claim descent from the Irish High King
Fionn MacCumhail. The Merovingian
conversion to Christianity was almost wholly political, rather than being
symptomatic of a spiritual awakening, so it would have made sense for them to
have "discovered" they derived from their new god.
Of
course, the legend could still be based on a false tradition; but I've
discovered a bit more about the origin of the Grail legend since I wrote that
novel. Curiously, some of these things
rarely get mentioned in any of the endless discussions of the legend.
The
earliest extant version of the legend as such (and I'll come back later to that
qualification) is Perceval: or the Story of the Grail by the 12th
century French poet Chrétien de Troyes.
Not a great deal is known of Chrétien's life, but he appears to have
enjoyed the patronage of both Countess Marie of Champagne and Count Philip of
Flanders. He was one of a generation of
French poets who took the Welsh legends of King Arthur and dressed them up in
an idealised form of 12th-century chivalry.
Although
probably not the first, he was undoubtedly the best of the first wave of
romance-writers, treating his subjects with an effortless blend of mystery,
beauty and humour. His treatment of
Lancelot pokes fun at the excesses of courtly love, even while portraying the
hero venturing into the hazards of a magical land, while an episode where
Gawain is targeted by a little girl who's decided he's to be "her
knight" is comedy of the highest order.
Nevertheless,
his most lasting legacy is the unfinished Perceval. This relates a number of adventures of the
titular knight, but the key moment comes when he arrives at the castle of the
wounded Fisher King. At dinner, he sees
a strange sight:
While they were talking of this and that, out of a room came a youth
holding a white lance grasped by the middle; and he passed by between the fire
and those seated on the couch. And everyone present could see the white lance
with its shining head; and from the tip of the lance-head oozed a drop of
blood, a crimson drop that ran right down to the lad's hand...Thereupon two
other youths came, holding in their hands pure gold candlesticks inlaid with
black enamel. The lads carrying the candelabras were extremely handsome. At
least ten candles were burning in each candelabra.
A damsel, who came with the youths and was fair and attractive and
beautifully adorned, held in both hands a grail. Once she had entered with this
grail that she held, so great a radiance appeared that the candles lost their
brilliance just as the stars do at the rising of the sun or moon. After her
came another maiden, holding a silver carving-dish. The grail, which proceeded
ahead, was of pure refined gold... *
Perceval
longs to know the meaning of this procession and, most of all, who was
served from that grail, but is afraid the question would be impertinent and
so holds his tongue. The next morning,
he finds the castle deserted and, when he leaves to search for its inhabitants,
the door is locked behind him. He
subsequently learns that, if he had asked the question he'd longed to, the
Fisher King would have been healed, but he's now he's now condemned both the
King and his land to misery.
Perceval
vows to search — not for the Grail itself, but to discover the meaning of what
he saw. Unfortunately, Chrétien died
without completing the work and without revealing the answer to the riddle.
This
was the first appearance of the Grail, but the story wasn't entirely
original. It may have been based on the
Welsh story Peredur Son of Efrawg, one of the stories collected in the Mabinogion. I say "may have been" because the
earliest extant version of Peredur is believed to date from later, and
some scholars think that the influence was the other way round. I think it's more likely, though, that
Chrétien drew on an earlier, lost version of Peredur.
In the parallel scene to that quoted above, Peredur sees a severed head
being carried, and it seems to me that the absence of the best-known element of
Chrétien's story makes it unlikely that the Welsh author was drawing on the
French.
Nevertheless,
while Peredur is a very similar story, it doesn't feature the Grail, and
it's fair to assume that Chrétien originated this crucial element. However, this wasn't the Sangreal, or the
Holy Grail, or even the Grail — merely a grail. A grail was, in fact, not a cup at all, but
a serving-dish. The word subsequently
fell out of use, and it's likely that the authors who rewrote and finished
Chrétien's tale (some of whom weren't French-speakers in any case) didn't know
what it meant. It's during this phase
of the legend that it became a cup and was identified with the cup of the Last
Supper.
This
doesn't mean, of course, that Chrétien might not have intended something very
similar. Although steeped in Celtic
magic, his stories were fundamentally Christian, and it's entirely possible
that the procession Perceval witnessed was meant to symbolise the Eucharist. But the Grail was only an element of that
procession, although an important one.
Since
the Grail wasn't originally a cup, the legend can hardly have originated, as
sometimes claimed, with the alleged discovery in Jerusalem of the cup used by
Christ, giving rise to a whole raft of Templar conspiracy theories. Since it wasn't originally called the
Sangreal, there's no reason to believe it symbolised the royal blood, real or
imagined. And it wasn't an object to be
found or possessed, merely a context to be understood. John Boorman's film Excalibur perhaps
comes closest to the spirit of the original, though he still portrays the grail
as a chalice.
The
concept may have been influenced by the cauldron of rebirth — a dish is a
receptacle, after all, though it's quite a stretch to get from a cauldron to a
dish. This appears in Welsh legend, but
is probably related to the Dagda's Cauldron, one of the four treasures of
Ireland. The others are the Sword of
Victory, the Spear of Lugh and the Stone of Destiny (said to be the Stone of
Scone, until recently housed in Westminster Abbey, but now returned to
Scotland). It's worth noting that a
spear also figures in the procession, and Perceval is given a magical sword by
the Fisher King. Perhaps Chrétien intended
to introduce a magical stone later on.
So
does any of this matter? Well, not if
all you want to do is write a good story.
All legends develop, and a storyteller has the right to draw upon
whichever stage of it suits his or her tale and to give it whatever twist is
convenient. Authors from Malory to
Monty Python have written wonderful versions of the Quest for the Holy Grail,
and I wouldn't want them any different.
As long as they don't start claiming that it's all fact.
What
I do object to is the way that endless "experts" are overpaid for
creating TV documentaries about the origins of the Grail legend when they
clearly haven't bothered to read the original version, or at least consider its
implications. The story Chrétien tells
is at least as intriguing as, and far more entertaining than, any fiction about
cups found in Jerusalem or the descendents of Christ, and it deserves pride of
place in the legend's history.
And
what of my novel? I feel reluctant to
perpetuate falsities that are already too widespread, even in the name of a
good story. Anyway, it would need
plenty of fixing, even without that aspect.
Maybe someday I'll rewrite it, without the misleading version of the
Grail legend. Or maybe I'll write
something actually based on Chrétien.
Or both.
*
quoted from Arthurian Romances by Chrétien de Troyes, translated by D.
D. R. Owen, published by J.M. Dent, 1987
Monday, July 15, 2013
Evolution of a Villain
When I first began to
consciously write epic fantasy, in my mid-teens, the villain of my story, The
Winter Legend, was the obvious type of Dark Lord, threatening to conquer
and oppress the world for no very apparent reason. That's part of the standard Dark Lord job description, after
all. He was a little different from
most, since he was referred to as the Winter Lord, and his primary aim was to
spread winter everywhere he conquered, though I imagine that wasn't entirely
uninfluenced by the White Witch of Narnia.
As he develops through The
Winter Legend (and as he'll be presented in the prequel I intend to start
work on soon) Kargor shows every side of his character, from the personable man
who adores his friends and is adored in return to the frightening image of
someone who's willing to sacrifice anybody, however special they are to him, in
order to ensure his own safety.
At first, this Winter Lord,
who eventually acquired the name Kargor, had little presence as a
character. Like Sauron, he was a
distant menace, seen in occasional distant glimpses, but mostly by the effects
of his oppression. When he finally made
a direct appearance, though, he pretty much ran the gamut of Standard Dark Lord
Behaviour, insulting and abusing enemies and minions alike. I think I resisted having him cackle, but
little else.
Not that the character was
entirely generic — I did put some thought into the psychology. Kargor has a flame (now called the Tryst
Flame, though it was unnamed back then) which ensures his invulnerability, and
I did somewhat develop the duality of the confidence and the paranoia this
gives him.
Nevertheless, there was
little originality about him, even though the heroes (male and female) were
evolving nicely from idealistic action junkies into vulnerable, reluctant
heroes. Fortunately, the version I
wrote in the late 70s failed to interest publishers, and when I finally came
back to The Winter Legend, ten years later, I'd evolved enough as a
writer and a person to rethink my villain.
There were two main
problems. Well, three, counting the
simple fact that the character was just plain clichéd. The first was that I had another, more minor
villain, a mortal king, who was almost exactly the same. There was actually more justification with
this character, Jekaini. For one thing,
he was very much in the tradition of rulers who are delicately balanced between
insane and psychopathic — my original idea for him was a kind of mash-up of the
Emperor Caligula, Adolf Hitler and Idi Amin.
For another, he only makes a couple of brief personal appearances, and
the main point about him is the effects of his personal and political tyranny,
especially on his children. This worked
well enough, but I didn't want two such similar villains.
The other problem was a more
practical issue. When we first meet
Kargor, he's only recently been defeated and exiled, yet within a year he's
established a kingdom and gathered a large, loyal following. While minions might take abuse from a
successful leader whose power they hope to share, why would anyone follow a
powerless exile who clearly doesn't value them?
The revised character who
emerged from my cogitations was very different: pleasant, charismatic, cultured
and genuinely loyal to his friends and followers, yet still vacillating between
confidence in his invulnerability and morbid terror of what might happen to him
if he were to lose this. Kargor's
overwhelming concern is his own safety, and it's this obsession — treated very
much as an addiction — that leads him conquer and commit atrocities.
He also gives some hints of
his earlier life, and the circumstances that led to the obsessions and grudges
that drive him. I've recently begun
writing stories about that very young Kargor (then called Karaghr, or Kari) and
his girlfriend Failiu. Two largely
clueless teenagers dabbling in sorcery they don't fully understand, they are
charming, amoral and driven by insatiable curiosity as they wander through
their world. Nevertheless, in these
stories (including The Temple of Taak-Resh) Kari and Fai are the people the reader's meant to root for, and I find
it fascinating to explore this very different side of my villain.
It's been largely through
this process that I've discovered a simple fact which, however many older
and/or wiser people might tell us this, each author has to discover for
themselves — that villains, like heroes, are nothing more or less than
people. They may be people we admire or
people we hope we'll never encounter, but people. It's when we let go of thinking about the creation of a Villain
that we can finally start creating genuine villains.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









